Method Of Agreement Logic

But what is sufficient evidence of causality? Although we generally use conditional statements to express our causal beliefs, the logical link, known as material involvement, seems to capture only part of what we have in mind. Although we see the cause as a necessary and sufficient condition for effect, our cause-and-effect concept does not cover our entire concept of cause and effect. There may be less here than the eye strikes; David Hume pointed out that our causal convictions are unjustifiable, even if they come on their own. (What Mill and his proponents describe as the common method cannot be this indirect method of difference, but a dual method of agreement, in which a number of positive instances identify a necessary condition and a number of negative instances a sufficient condition. Such a combination is redundant with the adoption of one of the first two species, but not if the hypothesis is further relaxed.) The method of simultaneous variation, such as the one already studied, must be a form of amplative induction; We want to argue from covariation observed in some cases to a general rule of covariation that also covers uncurred cases. To interpret this method, we need a broader approach to the cause than we have applied so far. One of the causes of P in the F field should not be taken as a necessary and sufficient condition, but as something whose size of P, in F, depends functionally. For our present purpose, this simply means that there is a real law-type phrase that, within F, relates the size of one point to that of the other. The full cause will be something in this sense that the size of P depends entirely on F, i.e. the size of P is clearly determined by the orders of magnitude of the factors that constitute the complete cause. Perhaps the best way to introduce Mills` methods is an example.

Suppose your family went to a buffet dinner together, but when you got home, you started to feel sick and feel stomach pains. How do you determine the cause of the disease? Suppose you create a table of foods that are taken by each member of the family: Although mills methods are an important part of the serious study of natural phenomena, they have significant restrictions.

Comments are closed.